Friday, March 7, 2014

LIRR Pension Error May Cost Widow Nearly $27,000

350 Old Country Road, Suite 205, Garden City, NY 11530
877-791-8076 / StoberLaw.com 

A clerical LIRR pension error has left the widow of a retired train engineer owing $26,707.  The MTA is now demanding their money back.  Shirley Findel was informed that she could correct the overpayment through a deduction of $240 from her benefits each month.  However, the 80 year old woman says that any reduction to her benefits would impose a financial hardship. 

Shirley Findel was only informed of the error after she notified the pension administrators of her husband’s death.  They are now asking for payment 18 and a half years later.  Shirley feels this payment is an unfair burden.  However, the MTA spokesman is defending the demand for repayment.  The MTA says that the pension plan “is obligated to correct this error and seek to recover the overpayment.”

New York University law professor Brookes Billman feels that if the overpayment is not recovered, it could burden the pension system.  This would cause problems for others who rely on the pension system after retirement.

Lee Adler, a lecturer in collective bargaining and labor law and Cornell University’s School of Industrial Labor Relations feels that although the MTA may have a legal right to recoup the money, there are serious moral concerns at hand.


The Law Offices of Louis D. Stober Jr. are experienced in handling employment law cases.  Our experience, combined with our successful track record makes us Long Island’s premier law firm.  If you have an employment law case, contact our office for a consultation by calling 877-791-8076.  Don’t forget to like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter for the latest news stories and legal tips.